Hi everyone,
Late last year someone uploaded items from Schein's collection Cymbalum Sionium and Musica boscareccia. There work pages already for the individual songs in these collections. Should we:
1. add the individual songs to the collection pages and delete the work pages?
or
2. move works from Cymbalum to the individual song work pages (since there are just a few), and ?? with Musica b.
or
3. Just cross reference everything.
or
4. (??? your suggestion below)
Scale of work:
Cymbalum - 30 works of 5-12 voices (pdf sizes 7-15 pages each)
Musica b. - 50 works (pdf sizes 2-?? pages)
Also:
PML has already linked the Sämtliche Werke page to all the individual song work pages (=lot's o nice work).
Suggestions? Thanks.
Johann Hermann Schein - some guidance requested
Moderators: kcleung, Wiki Admins
-
homerdundas
- active poster
- Posts: 148
- Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 1:54 am
- notabot: YES
- notabot2: Bot
- Location: Dundas, Ontario CANADA
-
pierre.chepelov
- active poster
- Posts: 144
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 2:06 pm
- notabot: YES
- notabot2: Bot
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
Re: Johann Hermann Schein - some guidance requested
I had the same question in mind a few days ago...
My vote is : 1. because
(cent #1) each Schein publication seems to be a coherent opus and is convenient to deal with;
(cent #2) it is so weird to see Allein Gott and Alleluja between Ach, Amor and Als Filli schön...
[EDIT] Vote 4 : maybe split the Musica boscareccia into its three parts?
My vote is : 1. because
(cent #1) each Schein publication seems to be a coherent opus and is convenient to deal with;
(cent #2) it is so weird to see Allein Gott and Alleluja between Ach, Amor and Als Filli schön...
[EDIT] Vote 4 : maybe split the Musica boscareccia into its three parts?