All my solidarity to Feldmhaler

carmar1791 · Post by **carmar1791** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:19 pm

Thank you for all!You have all my esteem and comprehension .
It's a great idea and a great project.
BUT BUT BUT........
Why throw all away?
I understand your situation,I understand all stress and pressure you have.
I think you need to sleep some days and after you will see things more
clearly.
I know we don't have money to support a legal battle also if we have all the right reasons of this world.
So if the problems are only 100 or 200 files why don't you momentary delete those?Meanwhile we have only to find a library ,a society etc. that can gives IMSLP a legal or authoritative cover.
By the way , Why throw away all that work? In the worst case we have only to delete 200 , 300 files or less (1000 more or less if you restrict PD law to life + 70).
I stress that 90% of our files are PD everywhere without doubt.
An other thing is the fact that IMSLP is a commitment too heavy for you.
But I think you'll find many people that would like to help .
For all about server bill and other costs we could find forms of pubblicity that can sponsor (printing pubblicity on score too etc.)
For these reasons I think IMSLP should reopen.
In any case THANK YOU FOR ALL.
Ciao Carmar1791

[/i][/b]

Post by **Funper** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:22 pm

(1000 more or less if you restrict PD law to life + 70).

Never! we would reduce ourselves. it's better being died than a crippling.

Post by **Matthieu** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:26 pm

The solution: Funper takes the whole site and reopens it as the head. He has obviously all the qualities and bravery for this

Post by **Funper** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:28 pm

it is more honorable being died than a crippling. i would take over the site but i am afraid that i wouldn't give a shit for copyright laws, and it would probably end up being a site like piratebay.

Post by **Matthieu** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:30 pm

it is more honorable being died than a crippling.

So do not hesitate: just go

i would take over the site but i am afraid that i wouldn't give a shit for copyright laws, and it would probably end up being a site like piratebay.

For the rest... no comment

Post by **Funper** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:32 pm

Funper
Joined: 11 Jun 2006

i don't think so.

carmar1791 · Post by **carmar1791** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 12:46 pm

I told to delete that files only momentary.
The problem in the menwhile is to find a legal cover......
Better crippling than dead,deads can do nothing,cripplings can hit again.....

Post by **Yagan Kiely** » Sat Oct 20, 2007 9:57 pm

Please you two, at times like this, we cannot bicker.

We need not restrict ourselves if we IP ban (which CAN be easily worked around) EU and the US.

IMSLP had 15,000 scores, more than anywhere else, 14,000 is not a cripple, it is merely a scratch, as 14,000 is still more than anywhere else.

Deliberations and discussions are being held for various reasons and with various people/organisations regarding the future of IMSLP, I apologise for closing this thread, which under normal circumstances would be a legitimate thread. However, the current status of IMSLP is not normal, and is quite frankly slightly unstable. It is because of this I need to close all threads with a similar topic as to stop the forum from flooding in such times.

Apologies again,
AW7