IMSLP Forums

Posted: **Fri Jul 12, 2013 7:22 am**

I noticed in the earlier (non-Kalmus) print of the Malherbe/Weingartner edition of Berlioz's Symphonie Fantastique, the editors made the decision to swap several of the trombone and ophicleide (or tuba, in this case) parts in the fourth movement, completely eliminating the third trombone's infamous pedal tones. I am sure Berlioz would see them taken to the scaffold for such a heinous act!

Someone might consider mentioning this in the "misc. notes" section for that score.

Posted: **Sat Jul 13, 2013 6:52 am**

Someone might consider retypesetting this score! You've uncovered one of the reasons why some people retypeset some scores.

Posted: **Mon Jul 22, 2013 9:08 am**

I've added the notes to those edition sections.

IMSLP Forums

I would write a letter to the editor if he weren't so dead!

I would write a letter to the editor if he weren't so dead!

Re: I would write a letter to the editor if he weren't so de

Re: I would write a letter to the editor if he weren't so de