IMSLP Forums

Hi everyone,
Late last year someone uploaded items from Schein's collection Cymbalum Sionium and Musica boscareccia. There work pages already for the individual songs in these collections. Should we:

1. add the individual songs to the collection pages and delete the work pages?
or
2. move works from Cymbalum to the individual song work pages (since there are just a few), and ?? with Musica b.
or
3. Just cross reference everything.
or
4. (??? your suggestion below)

Scale of work:
Cymbalum - 30 works of 5-12 voices (pdf sizes 7-15 pages each)
Musica b. - 50 works (pdf sizes 2-?? pages)

Also:
PML has already linked the Sämtliche Werke page to all the individual song work pages (=lot's o nice work).

Suggestions? Thanks.

I had the same question in mind a few days ago...
My vote is : 1. because
(cent #1) each Schein publication seems to be a coherent opus and is convenient to deal with;
(cent #2) it is so weird to see Allein Gott and Alleluja between Ach, Amor and Als Filli schön...

[EDIT] Vote 4 : maybe split the Musica boscareccia into its three parts?