IMSLP Forums

I have noted that the key in the description of the work is given as D minor. Although the 2nd movement Scherzo is indeed in the minor, the actual key of the work is D Major.

The page has been updated to reflect the correct key, thanks.

Why do you say the correct key is D major? The first movement is in D minor. Having nothing to guide you but listening to the work, how would you be able to tell that it was in D major and not D minor? Nothing about it, afaik, harmonically, distinguishes the key sequence from several Haydn D minor symphonies- first movement in D minor ending in D major (and only in its last few bars!!), finale in D major...

But then again, since Beethoven's 5th symphony is in C major and Mahler's 9th is in D-flat major, by general agreement, I can see how the finale, not the first movement, is used to decide these things as a general thing.