Marshall Fine Victimae Paschali
Posted: Sat Oct 22, 2016 2:11 pm
I am trying to enter manuscript scans for Marshall Fine's Victimae Paschali:
http://imslp.org/wiki/Victimae_Paschali ... _Marshall)
Based on the materials, the sequence of events appears to be this:
1983: Fine composes "Op.35" for solo organ
1983: FIne arranges it for solo piano as "Op.35a"
late-2000's: Fine typesets the piano version as "Op.35"
2014: Elaine Fine (composer's sister) creates IMSLP page as "Op.35" for solo piano
It seems like the piece ought to be listed for solo organ and the piano version listed as an arrangement. However the composers typeset listing the piano version as plain "Op.35" may argue against that. What's the best course? If it should be coded for organ rather than piano, can I recode it? Or should I let moderators do that?
http://imslp.org/wiki/Victimae_Paschali ... _Marshall)
Based on the materials, the sequence of events appears to be this:
1983: Fine composes "Op.35" for solo organ
1983: FIne arranges it for solo piano as "Op.35a"
late-2000's: Fine typesets the piano version as "Op.35"
2014: Elaine Fine (composer's sister) creates IMSLP page as "Op.35" for solo piano
It seems like the piece ought to be listed for solo organ and the piano version listed as an arrangement. However the composers typeset listing the piano version as plain "Op.35" may argue against that. What's the best course? If it should be coded for organ rather than piano, can I recode it? Or should I let moderators do that?