IMSLP Forums

I discovered a set of anonymous pieces -- excerpts, as it turns out -- here on IMSLP.
Link: http://imslp.org/wiki/6_Morceaux_Anonymes_(Anonymous)

I am dying to know who wrote No. 4, the song with piano.

Here's what I've found out:
- The poem is by Andre Foulon de Vauxl.
- The pieces were part of a contest (January 1905 issue of Musica, No. 28) to guess the composer.
- The answers were published in the April 1905 issue, No. 31.
- The composers were Debussy, Saint-Saens, Cecile Chaminade, Jules Massenet, Rudolphe Berger, and Gaston Serpette.

Of course, I can't find the issue with the answers anywhere, so I'm still left guessing. I think I've ruled out Debussy and Saint-Saens from other sources. Looks like Berger and Serpette wrote operettas, in a very different style than this. So... Chaminade? Massenet? Anyone familiar with this song? I'm dying to solve the mystery!!

The link contains no music.

The closing brace should be part of the link, then it works:
http://imslp.org/wiki/6_Morceaux_Anonymes_(Anonymous)

Fixed.

For certain it is not Debussy - the last piece of this group is known as "Morceau de concours" or "Assez vite et tres rhythmé":

http://imslp.org/wiki/Morceau_de_concou ... y,_Claude)

Based of the style of piano writing I would guess Massenet. He liked chordal accompaniments in the right hand without any bass (even in his operas: "Adieu, notre petite table" from Manon). A note from the book "Debussy and the Fragment" (available in preview on Google Books) on page 130 (footnote 30) seems to suggest that the order of composers is thus:

1 - Serpette
2- Saint-Saëns
3 - Chaminade
4 - Massenet
5 - Berger
6 - Debussy

Hope this helps!

Thanks so much, pocoallegro!