IMSLP Forums

GRAUPNER RECORDER CONCERTO GWV323 FURTHER ERROR in DARMSTADT SCORE: Apropos the above my MIDI playback has uncovered another error: In the Final movement (Recorder-part) at Bar 379 (Darmstadt)/Bar #218 (Kram) the eighth-note (quaver) is G, not F. This is a copyist-error arising no doubt from lesser-...

Apropos the above Graupner Recorder Concerto in F I have to report an error in the Recorder-part in the Opening Movement at Bar#45 in the Darmstadt m/s; I became aware the discrepancy in my MIDI playback of the Sibelius Score that I have produced viz: The last four notes in the Recorder Part produce...

I also bring to your attention confusion at Movt#4 bar 75 (traversa) and its answer (flauto) at bar 91; this is more difficult to resolve - the rhythm in the first beat of the affected bars are at odds in the Darmstadt parts, and it may well be that the flauto part is correct after all. In my 1952 r...

Thanks, Boccaccio and Rob Peters - for replies; they are extremely helpful; the traversa-imitation had not escaped my mind either. I have only just "discovered" how to access Landesbibliothek Darmstadt which has this work in parts-only. The recorder-part unbeknown to me is in the French Vi...

Re ERROR in RECORDER PART - Movement #1, Bar 15 The first sixteenth-note (semiquaver) in the third beat of bar#15 in the opening movement in the recorder part IS AN E NATURAL - NOT A C NATURAL. Assuming that the source is Barenreiter Hortus Musicus where the error originates, the printed note in the...

The recent inclusion of the Quintett h-moll for two transverse flutes, two voice-flutes and unfigured-bass (and the deletion of a d minor Quintet from the "wish-list") and attributed to John Loeillet - has prompted me to respond by the uploading of emails between myself (Palmerston North N...

I obtained the six sonatas Op3 (Nos 2,3,4,5,6 and 10) in the Schott (Mainz) edited by P. Fr. Scherber/A.Kutz prints of 1949; all attributed to J. (John of London) B. Loeillet (1680/1730) back in 1957. Sonata No5 (c-moll) was already known to me in a recording (Decca) of the Largo and Menuetto (Poco ...

I am wondering whether anybody else has confronted the copyist's error in Movement Three (Giga) of the above work? In the opening half of the Giga (comprising thirty-four bars) the Flauto #3 part has but twenty-six bars; a deficit of eight bars. I found that out when I was making a Sibelius V score ...

Re the above - I have to report that the page 23 (Walsh & Hare) is missing; this means that Sonata VI Opera Quarta is incomplete. It appears as if the Title Page was counted as Page One and so on. The sonata truncates into thin-air in the third movement (Corrente). I would be most appreciative i...